Recently, I saw a personal trainer talk about how nice people are scammed into questionable (and expensive) nutritional courses. Then I made the connection to publishing, and I’m sad now.
So here’s how you do it. (Hint: Don’t do this)
Let’s play the bad guy for a minute. You were an author first, but now you make much more money selling shovels and pickaxes than you ever would panning for gold. Writing books is for suckers. Marketing courses to aspiring authors is where the money is.
You claim to have all the answers to getting books flying off digital shelves, right? Your first strategy is to suck in the rubes and noobs. You go all over social media to promote your courses. You’re on every podcast when you make the big push. You pat yourself on the back so hard, you’re in serious danger of injuring your shoulder. Hundreds of desperate authors, maybe thousands over time, sign up to learn how to finally make Facebook, Google, TikTok, X, or Amazon ads work for them. They’re all just one click away from living at a resort in Fiji, or so you say.
Authors: When the pitch to boost your book income homes in on your inability to buy expensive Christmas presents and go on exotic vacations, watch out! They’re using cheap tactics to push your pain points to make the sale.
But here comes the bigger con:
Of all those new students the guru hauls up in his net, a few outliers will get positive results. Those few outliers will promote the next course and sing all the praises. Rinse and repeat, and each course gets bigger and more expensive. Huzzah! You’re a marketing genius! You’re the captain everyone looks to in hopes you can steer their ship past the rocks.
Except, uh-oh! For most authors, it won’t work. Don’t just focus on the outliers claiming staggering results.
This phenomenon is not unique to book marketing. Forbes will ballyhoo the latest investment guru on their cover each year because that’s how math works. One hedge fund manager will make the most each year, sure. But will you ever see that person on the top of the pile again? There is only one Warren Buffet per thousands of pretenders to his throne.
Some, but not all, reasons for book marketing failures:
- Put lipstick on a pig, it’s still a pig. Great marketing for the wrong book can, at best, spread the word fast that a lousy book is lousy.
- The cover art is wrong for its genre.
- The cover art is plain bad.
- Your blurb sucks.
- Your blurb doesn’t hit the expected tropes for its genre.
- Your book is fine, but its niche is too small, and you have too few reviews.
- Your book could sell well, but it can take an immense amount of experimentation to make the marketing stars align. In this case, the guru didn’t necessarily fail. You didn’t do the thing, or didn’t do it enough, or didn’t listen in class.
- You don’t have the budget to move that needle.
- Your chosen genre is cold, or just not hot enough to move the needle to justify the ad cost.
- What worked for ads in the past isn’t working now.
- Some successes don’t look so good on further examination. An outlier may proudly proclaim the gross, but never hint what the appearance of success cost them. Folks with huge ad spends can look great on social media, but a spreadsheet would tell the true tale: The ad spend was so heavy, their net is far, far less than their gross.
- Your book marketing guru is full of shit and uses the tactics noted above to build his Empire of Shit.
Solutions?
- Honestly assess your book’s marketability (or consult other authors with experience about its marketability).
- Save up for that ad budget.
- Focus on one ad platform at a time.
- Invest the time to learn from free resources (YouTube, TikTok, or near-free from books). That’ll save some cash and allow you to better judge the offerings from potential gurus in the future. (Not all book marketers are bad.)
- Be social with other authors and get recommendations for further guidance from trusted sources.
- Stalk your guru to see if his values align with yours. If he sounds like a dick, don’t sign up!
- Listen carefully to their answers for obfuscation. I asked a guru a test question. His answer was, “That’s a good question! (Condescending tone) That’s where you have to get creative. Next question…” Um…what? Thanks for the non-answer, douche canoe.*
- Check to see if your guru sells a lot of his or her own books.
- Be skeptical. If it sounds too good to be true, punch ’em in the spleen. Y’know…metaphorically.
*That’s douchebag in Canadian.
Filed under: book marketing, publishing, books, Marketing, publishing, Robert Chazz Chute, self-publishing, selling books, writer, writing








































